René Girard’s Mimetic Theory by Wolfgang Palaver [Summary]
The Book In Three Or More Sentences:
Unsurprisingly, as stated in the title, the book is a detailed examination of the most famous thesis by René Girard – the mimetic theory. The desire of the French philosopher is to explain human existence and also tell us why human relations are so prone to conflict and violence. The theory is based on some of the most influential novels in modern literature (The Brothers Karamazov, Madame Bovary, Don Quixote, and more). Therefore, in this book, Wolfgang Palaver examines and comments on the sources used by Rene.
The Core Idea:
We, humans, form our desires based on the desires of the surrounding people. The people we follow and hang out with transmit their desires to us, and they become ours. This realization not only shatters our precious perception of autonomy and uniqueness, but also explains why feelings like jealousy dominate our minds – when we desire the same things as others, we become rivals as we all long for the same objects.
Our own desires are a projection of the desires of others.
Violence emerges when two people want the same thing. And since we imitate each other, we end up being violent towards our closest friends.
When we strive to be someone we are not, we end up hating ourselves for not being who we really are.
Lesson #1: We’re Deeply Influenced By The Desires of The People Around
The core idea of the mimetic theory is captured in the following sentence: “Humans do not themselves know what to desire; as a result, they imitate the desires of others.”
Just like that, the concept of our uniqueness vanishes. Our perception of autonomy and independence is imaginary. We are, our ambitions, goals, and desires, according to Rene, just a reflection of the yearnings of the people around us.
Why is that?
Simple. We learn by imitating others. When we’re born, in order to cope with the obstacles that come our way, we copy the behavior of the people closest to us. Since we yet don’t know what is true and what actually works, it’s natural to consider the actions of others as right.
This is actually our main advantage over animals – our ability to adapt and “steal” tactics and strategies from the people forming our social circle. This instinct is essential for our survival.
And while there are obvious benefits of mimicking the actions of others, there are some really nasty side effects that emerge:
Envy: The feeling of envy emerges when others have things we’re unable to acquire.
Rivalry: Essentially, we all desire the same things. We imitate each other all the time after all. Eventually, we start to fight over these same objects.
Violence: Violence arises when two people direct their desires towards something specific – since they can’t both possess it, one of them might use force over the other.
The mimetic theory offers answers to all of these destructive patterns that are deeply rooted in our nature.
“Envy,” as the term is understood in everyday usage, is due to a feeling of impotence which we experience when another person owns a good we covet. . . . If we are merely displeased that another person owns a good, this can be an incentive for acquiring it through work, purchase, violence, or robbery. Envy occurs when we fail in doing so and feel powerless.” Max Scheler
Lesson #2: Hatred and Envy Are Feelings Inspired by The People Around us
How do you feel towards someone you don’t have anything in common? Someone you rarely see? Even if he’s obviously wealthier than you?
Probably indifferent. You don’t care. After all, he’s not part of your inner circle.
Totally different motives occupy your brain if we’re talking about your neighbor or your close friend.
This time, if say your next-door friend is part of the group of people you commonly see, he becomes a rival. A source of sadness if your life.
This happens for three main reasons:
Disappearance of difference: When two men are from different nationalities, from different classes, they have a lot of differences. These unsimilarities are not allowing us to wish what they wish and the opposite. If, however, we’re similar to the person we see, if we have things in common, disagreements and envy emerge. Mainly due to the fact that we seem equal on the surface.
Inability to adore ourselves: When our close friends have traits that are admirable, a feeling of hatred cripples inside us. After all, deep down, we want to feel good about ourselves. We fall, though, because the person in front of us is better. His superiority highlights our flaws. Thus, we feel incapable.
Desire the same things: At some point, people who have something in common will start to desire the same things. Since they’ll mimic their desires, it’s only a matter of time to start desiring objects which they are unable to both possess. When this happens, inner conflict forms in our minds.
For these reasons, the mimetic theory is also called the “theory of conflict.”
Since people imitate each other’s desires, they end up desiring the very same things. And when they desire the same things, they easily become rivals since they rarely can both reach the same objects, achievements, etc.
The conflicts resulting from this double idolatry of self and other are the principal source of human violence. When we are devoted to adoring our neighbor, this adoration can easily turn to hatred because we seek desperately to adore ourselves, and we fall.” René Girard
Hey there, sorry to interrupt…
Since you’ve come this far, it seems that you are really passionate about books and learning. I’m too! And while what I’m about to say next probably won’t quite excite you, I have to say it…
Look, this is members-only content.
(Already a member? You can log-in using this link, here.)
I digest acres of complex ideas from various books and morph my findings into straight to the point book summaries. The main goal is not only to help you understand the underlying ideas from famous, and not-so-famous, titles. But, also, to help you stay curious, inspired, and well-informed. Above all, though, I want to help you transition from a passive online consumer to an active mindful go-getter with a sense of purpose.
By becoming a supporting member, you’ll unlock a well-curated online selection of book summaries that aim to move you in the right direction.
You can join as a MONTHLY ($7 USD), YEARLY ($70 USD), or PATRON ($100 USD) member. Read more about the membership, here.